Well before Swallow's trial, concerns about Nesbitt's approach to investigating cases circulated among defense attorneys, painting him as an aggressive go-getter who would retaliate if he felt someone wasn't cooperating with him.īusinessman David Buttars went to prison in January 2017 for 1-15 years, only after Nesbitt pursued him and Buttars' former girlfriend several times through the courts with cases that still leave defense attorneys scratching their heads.Ĭara Tangaro was co-counsel with Williams and Brad Anderson on the Swallow case and represented two other clients who found themselves in Nesbitt's crosshairs-one of them Buttars. Shurtleff's attorneys disputed Nesbitt's affidavits in their motion to dismiss, arguing that the warrants contained dozens of "material omissions, misleading statements and outright mistruths." Shurtleff filed a misconduct complaint against Nesbitt with the Department of Public Safety late last year, and shortly after Swallow's acquittal also filed misconduct complaints against Isakson and his boss, Michelle Pickens. All the while, Nesbitt sat behind the prosecutors, in many ways the author of the two investigations, since he wrote many of the affidavits and search warrants that judges signed so investigators could search, among others, Shurtleff's and Swallow's homes. Isakson suffered for his error, as Swallow's lead defense counsel Scott Williams tore into his credibility and accused him of perjury. Implode, because Judge Elizabeth Rhuby-Mills had ordered that topic was not to be broached before the jury. Nesbitt attended much, if not all, of the trial which saw Isakson implode on the stand when he testified as to why the Department of Justice declined to prosecute Swallow and former AG Mark Shurtleff. ![]() He was not their only possible choice of investigator to explain the case against Swallow there was also State Bureau of Investigation's Agent Scott Nesbitt. In the trial of former Utah Attorney General John Swallow, the Salt Lake County prosecutors put FBI Agent Jon Isakson on the stand. That investigator lays out a map for the jury, detailing how they came to the conclusion that the defendant committed a crime. ![]() When a prosecutor presents his or her case, a key initial witness often is the detective or investigator who assembled evidence that a judge deemed sufficient to warrant a trial.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |